← Insights

    Why I Left TIAA After 17 Years—and What It Taught Me About Serving Clients Well

    After nearly two decades as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor at TIAA, one of the most trusted names in academic retirement planning, I made the difficult decision to leave. Here's why—and how it's shaped our approach at Radiant Wealth Management.

    Respecting TIAA's Legacy While Moving Forward

    Let me start with something important: TIAA is a remarkable organization with a noble mission. Founded in 1918 through Andrew Carnegie's vision to provide retirement security for educators, TIAA pioneered the first guaranteed lifetime income product for those who dedicate their careers to education and research.

    The traditional annuity that remains at TIAA's core is, in many ways, still true to Carnegie's vision—providing stability, guaranteed income, and financial security to generations of faculty members.

    I believe in that mission. I still do. As the son of someone who worked in academia, I've always felt a personal connection to TIAA's mission—helping those who dedicate their lives to education retire with dignity. And that part of TIAA—the traditional guaranteed annuity—continues to operate with the not-for-profit structure and participant focus that makes it unique in the financial landscape.

    When Institutional Scale Meets Individual Needs

    Over my 17 years at TIAA, I worked with hundreds of faculty members and administrators across dozens of institutions. I built relationships, solved problems, and helped many educators transition successfully into retirement.

    At the heart of it, TIAA constantly balances a complex dual mission: serving both the institutions that hire them and the individual participants who rely on them. These priorities don't always align, and advisors are often caught in the middle.

    But as TIAA grew, I began to see how institutional priorities—like revenue generation and asset growth—could sometimes compete with what was best for individual clients:

    •     Advisors carried large books of business. As client rosters expanded, the ability to offer truly personalized planning became harder to sustain. Even with good intentions, there simply wasn't enough time for deep work with each person. When I left TIAA, I had 500 clients I was responsible for on an ongoing basis. Even with the best of intentions, that volume made it difficult to do the kind of deep, thoughtful planning I believe in.

    •     The pressure to bring in assets intensified. Internal incentives were often tied to consolidating client accounts, regardless of whether that move was tax-efficient or in the client's long-term best interest.

    •     Growth targets took priority. Advisors were expected to keep adding new clients—year after year—while continuing to manage their existing book. That stretch made it harder to build long-term, trust-based relationships.

    •     Customization was constrained. While the core TIAA offerings were solid, many complex situations required tools and strategies outside what the institutional platform allowed.

    These weren't failures of intention. They were the natural trade-offs that come with scale. But over time, they created a growing disconnect between how I believed I could best serve my clients—and what the system was built to support.

    I remember working with a client—an accomplished researcher with thoughtful views on diversification—who wanted part of her portfolio allocated to municipal bond ladders, a donor-advised fund strategy, and a modest gold position. All reasonable, well-aligned with her goals. She wasn't chasing trends—she was making thoughtful, values-aligned decisions about her giving and long-term risk exposure.

    But the platform didn't support muni ladders unless the allocation exceeded $1 million. The model portfolios didn't allow for nontraditional assets like gold or charitable planning tools. More than that, the models favored proprietary investments, and there was steady encouragement to keep client dollars within the TIAA platform.

    I wasn't saying, “This is a bad idea.” I was saying, “We can't do that here.” And that didn't sit right with me.

    The Birth of Radiant Wealth Management

    The decision to leave TIAA wasn't made lightly. It came after years of reflection on a simple question: How could I best serve the academic community I'd come to know and respect?

    Establishing Radiant Wealth Management was my answer—a practice built specifically around:

    •     Depth over breadth. Working with fewer clients but providing more comprehensive service to each one.

    •     True independence. The freedom to recommend solutions based solely on client needs, without institutional constraints or product limitations.

    •     Expanded capabilities. Access to a wider range of investment options, planning techniques, and technological tools.

    •     Time for relationship-building. The capacity to truly understand each client's unique story, priorities, and concerns.

    The irony wasn't lost on me: to better serve the academic community I'd dedicated my career to, I needed to step away from the institution created specifically for that community.

    The Hybrid Approach: Partnering with TIAA Where It Excels

    Here's what might surprise some readers: despite leaving TIAA, I still regularly recommend their Traditional Annuity to clients when appropriate.

    The not-for-profit structure of TIAA's guaranteed annuity—with its favorable interest rates, unique crediting method, and lifetime income options—remains one of the most valuable retirement tools available to academics. No other financial firm offers anything quite like it.

    Our approach at Radiant is to partner with TIAA where they excel:

    •     We help clients maintain and optimize their Traditional Annuity positions

    •     We guide strategic decisions about partial annuitization when appropriate

    •     We provide education on TIAA's unique features and benefits

    Meanwhile, we manage other aspects of clients' financial lives—from investment portfolios to tax planning, estate considerations to retirement projections—with the expanded tools and customization that independence allows.

    The Shift from Institutional to Independent Advising

    It wasn't until I left TIAA that I fully understood the difference between institutional advising and truly independent guidance.

    In an institutional setting, even with the best intentions, advisors operate within defined parameters. There are approved solutions, established processes, and institutional priorities that shape the advisor-client relationship.

    Independence removes those constraints. It allows for:

    •     Objective analysis across the entire financial landscape

    •     Custom portfolios built for specific situations rather than model allocations

    •     Integrated planning that considers all aspects of a client's financial life

    •     Technology integration that provides a unified view of finances

    •     Creative problem-solving without institutional limitations

    For some clients, these differences might seem subtle. For others—particularly those with complex situations involving multiple institutions, retirement plans, inheritance considerations, or unique goals—the impact can be substantial.

    When to Consider Working with an Independent Advisor

    I'm often asked when academics should consider working with an independent advisor versus staying with TIAA exclusively. My answer is nuanced:

    •     If you have a relatively straightforward situation with most assets at a single institution and standard retirement goals, TIAA's advisors can provide solid guidance.

    •     If your situation involves complexity across multiple areas—tax planning, estate considerations, special needs planning, business interests, or significant assets outside retirement plans—an independent perspective may add substantial value.

    •     If you value deep relationship-based planning with an advisor who has the time and capacity to truly know your situation, independent practices often provide more opportunity for this depth.

    •     If you want innovative solutions beyond standard offerings, independence typically offers greater flexibility.

    There's no universal right answer. The question is what approach best serves your specific needs and preferences.

    Reflections on the Journey

    Looking back on this transition, I've come to a deeper appreciation for both TIAA's institutional strengths and the unique value of independent advice.

    TIAA provides stable, reliable solutions to a broad community of educators and researchers. Its mission remains vital, and its core offerings—especially the Traditional Annuity—continue to serve participants well.

    Independent advice offers depth, customization, and a fiduciary approach unconstrained by institutional parameters.

    The best outcomes often come from recognizing and leveraging the strengths of each—which is precisely what we strive to do at Radiant Wealth Management.

    The Path Forward

    For faculty members and administrators navigating their financial futures, I offer this perspective:

    •     Appreciate TIAA's unique strengths, particularly in guaranteed income solutions

    •     Recognize the potential limitations of any single-institution approach

    •     Consider whether your situation might benefit from complementary independent guidance

    The decision I made to leave TIAA after 17 years wasn't about rejecting an institution I respected. It was about creating space for a different kind of service—one that builds on TIAA's strengths while addressing areas where independence offers distinct advantages.

    That's the spirit that drives our work at Radiant Wealth Management: honoring what works well, improving what could be better, and always putting client needs at the center of every recommendation.

    If you're curious about how an independent perspective might complement your existing TIAA relationship, I'm here to help. Together, we can explore whether a hybrid approach might better serve your financial future.

    Ready for a Conversation That's Centered on You?

    Wondering how independent advice might work alongside your TIAA accounts? Schedule a 30-minute Financial Transition Review

    If you've ever wondered whether you could get the best of both worlds—TIAA's stability and independent guidance tailored to your goals—you're not alone. Let's talk about how to make that work for you.

    Daniel Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®

    Managing Partner, Sr. Wealth Management Advisor

    A: 110 Washington Ave., 3rd Floor, North Haven, CT 06473

    P: (475) 234.5965

    M: (860) 748.2552

    E: dan.fagan@radiantwm.com

    About Dan

    Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience—including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor—Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most.

     

    Advisory services offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure.

    This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Investing involves risk and possible loss of principal capital. No advice may be rendered by NewEdge Advisors unless a client service agreement is in place.

    California Residents: We take protecting your data and privacy very seriously. As of January 1, 2020, the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) provides additional rights to residents of California. You may view our data privacy statement or exercise your rights here: Do not sell my personal information.


    About Dan Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience, including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor, Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most.

    This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Individual circumstances vary. Please consult qualified professionals for advice specific to your situation. Advisory services are offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure.