← Insights

    Should I Annuitize My TIAA?

    A faculty member's guide to the annuitize, roll over, or wait decision, drawing on seventeen years inside TIAA and the years since on the other side of the desk.

    If you have been a faculty member for any length of time, your retirement assets are probably with TIAA. Most are. And if you are approaching retirement, you have probably started running into a wall of options that doesn't quite resemble what your friends in the corporate world face.

    There are essentially three things you can do with TIAA at retirement: annuitize some or all of it, roll some or all of it to an IRA, or leave it where it is and take income gradually. Each has trade-offs. Each is right for some people and wrong for others. And the way TIAA Traditional is structured means the choice isn't just financial. It's also about timing, control, and what you want the next thirty years to look like.

    Let me try to lay this out clearly.

    Start with TIAA Traditional

    Most faculty I work with have a substantial portion of their TIAA balance in Traditional, often without realizing what it actually is. It's not a mutual fund. It's a guaranteed account, backed by TIAA's general account, that has paid a competitive rate of interest for decades.

    The catch is that liquidity is limited. Money you put into Traditional in different years is held in different vintages, each with its own crediting rate, and you generally can't move it out in a lump sum. Withdrawals are governed by specific rules tied to the type of contract you hold.

    The contract type matters. Retirement Annuity (RA) and Group Retirement Annuity (GRA) contracts are the most restrictive on Traditional balances and require a Transfer Payout Annuity (TPA) for any non-annuitized exit, paid out over nine years and a day. Retirement Choice (RC) contracts, introduced in 2006, ease that somewhat. Traditional balances under RC can generally be moved in 84 monthly installments over seven years. Supplemental Retirement Annuity (SRA), Group Supplemental Retirement Annuity (GSRA), and Retirement Choice Plus (RCP) contracts allow full liquidity on Traditional balances. Most faculty hold a mix of these, often without realizing which contract holds which balance. The first move at retirement, before any decision about what to do, is to find out.

    Why does this matter at retirement? Because the rules on Traditional are part of why annuitization exists as an option in the first place. Annuitizing a Traditional balance gives you immediate access to that money in the form of guaranteed lifetime income. The same balance, accessed through a TPA on an RA or GRA, takes nearly a decade to fully extract. The structure of Traditional is built around annuitization. That's not an accident. TIAA was founded to provide lifetime income to faculty, and Traditional is the engine that does it. Whether annuitization is the right answer in your specific case depends on the rest of your picture, but the product itself is doing what it was designed to do.

    The three options

    Annuitize. You convert some portion of your TIAA balance into a guaranteed income stream for life. You can choose single life, joint life with a spouse, or various combinations with guaranteed periods of ten or twenty years. Once you annuitize, that money is no longer an asset you can spend down. It becomes income.

    The upside is that the income is guaranteed for as long as you live, and TIAA's annuitization rates have historically been competitive relative to the broader annuity market. The Traditional annuitization rate in particular reflects TIAA's general account performance and has, in many years, exceeded what an outside insurer would offer for the same premium. Mitchell, Poterba, Warshawsky and Brown's work on the "money's worth" of annuities is the foundational research here, and TIAA's offerings have generally fared well in those comparisons.

    The trade-off is reduced flexibility. Once annuitized, you can't pull a lump sum out for a roof, a child's wedding, or a long-term care need. Annuitized assets pass on through the contract rather than as part of the estate, though guaranteed period riders and joint life options preserve more legacy than people realize. The legacy isn't zero. It's structured.

    Roll over. You move your TIAA balance, or part of it, into an IRA. This gives you full control over how the money is invested, when you take it, and how it's distributed at your death. Beneficiary designations are clean, withdrawals can be timed for tax efficiency, and the assets remain part of your estate.

    There are real benefits on this side of the ledger. Once in an IRA, after age 70½ you can make Qualified Charitable Distributions, sending up to roughly $108,000 per year in 2026 directly from the IRA to charity, satisfying part or all of your required minimum distribution while keeping that amount out of taxable income. Investment options widen considerably beyond the TIAA menu. Roth conversions can also be executed in low-income years, though some 403(b) plans now allow in-plan Roth conversions, so the IRA isn't always required for that step.

    On beneficiary planning, the honest answer is that for most faculty with simple designations, the difference between TIAA and an IRA is small. Both allow primary and contingent beneficiaries, percentage splits, per stirpes language, trust beneficiaries, and spousal continuation. The IRA edge shows up in specific situations: complex trust planning, blended families with different distribution preferences for different beneficiary classes, or charitable beneficiary integration where the operational simplicity of an IRA-to-charity transfer matters. For straightforward designations like spouse-then-children, both options work well.

    There are also real trade-offs. Once you're in an IRA, the guaranteed income stream is gone. You're managing the money yourself, or with an advisor, and you're responsible for sequencing withdrawals across a retirement that could last thirty years. Traditional balances in restricted contracts can't be moved in a single transaction, which means a multi-year exit through a TPA or its equivalent.

    Fees also tend to go up. A 403(b) in a large university plan often runs at institutional pricing, which is usually lower than retail IRA pricing once you add advisory fees, fund expenses, and platform costs. Federal disclosure rules now require advisors recommending a rollover to compare those costs explicitly and document why the rollover is in the client's interest. That requirement exists because, on average, rollovers do increase the participant's cost. Sometimes the additional flexibility, the QCD access, the broader investment menu, or the planning capability is worth it. Sometimes it isn't. The disclosure exists to make sure the question is at least being asked.

    Wait. You leave the money in TIAA, draw income gradually, and let the structure stay as it is. RMDs will eventually force some level of withdrawal, but until then you have flexibility. You can take systematic withdrawals, you can layer in partial annuitization later, you can convert pieces to Roth in low-income years, you can adjust as circumstances change.

    This option gets less attention than it deserves. It's not glamorous, and no one is selling it to you, which is part of why it tends to be undersold.

    A word on the participating side

    One feature of TIAA Traditional that doesn't get nearly enough attention is that it is a participating annuity. That phrase doesn't mean much until you unpack it.

    A commercial fixed annuity from a typical insurer pays exactly what the contract says it will pay. The insurer keeps any excess from favorable claims experience or investment returns.

    TIAA is structured differently. Excess reserves, the funds TIAA accumulates beyond what's required to back its guarantees, are shared with participants in two ways. The first is additional amounts, sometimes called dividends, declared annually by the TIAA Board of Trustees. These can increase your accumulating balance during your working years and increase your annuity income in retirement. They are discretionary, not guaranteed. But they have been declared every year I have been watching the company, and that goes back nearly thirty years.

    The second is the loyalty bonus. This goes specifically to faculty who have been contributing to Traditional over a long career, and it shows up only when you annuitize. According to TIAA's actuarial work, over the most recent decade studied, faculty who contributed to Traditional throughout their careers received initial lifetime income that exceeded a new-money transfer of the same final balance in every one of 120 retirement months. The average advantage was 22.5%.

    That is not a small number. It changes the math on annuitization in a meaningful way for long-tenured faculty. The same balance, annuitized by someone who spent thirty years in Traditional, can generate substantially more income than the same balance annuitized by someone who just transferred in.

    TIAA has shared more than $79 billion with clients through these mechanisms since 2000.

    None of this guarantees future performance. The loyalty bonus and the additional amounts are both discretionary. Annuitization income is not guaranteed to increase over time, though historically it often has. But the structural design of Traditional, and the historical record, are a real reason to take annuitization seriously, especially if you have been contributing for decades.

    Most people pick a blend

    Most faculty I work with don't choose one option. They choose a blend.

    A common approach: annuitize enough to cover essential fixed expenses, leaving flexibility for the rest. The annuitized portion handles the floor. The non-annuitized portion handles inflation, surprises, and legacy goals. The exact split depends on your other guaranteed income sources, your spending pattern, your health, your spouse's situation, and your view of risk.

    The academic literature on annuitization, going back to Yaari's foundational 1965 paper, has long argued that fully rational households without bequest motives should annuitize a substantial share of their wealth. The fact that most people don't do this is known in the literature as the annuity puzzle. Real households have bequest motives. They worry about long-term care costs that an annuity won't cover. They want flexibility. They distrust insurers, even strong ones. The puzzle resolves once you account for these factors.

    There is also a counterintuitive finding worth knowing. Annuitizing a portion of your assets can, in some cases, leave more wealth to heirs than not annuitizing at all. The mechanism is straightforward. The annuitized portion handles a chunk of your ongoing income needs, which takes the draw pressure off the remaining portfolio. That portfolio stays invested longer and at a higher allocation to growth assets. Over a long retirement, the compounding effect can outweigh the assets surrendered to the annuity. Wade Pfau and others have modeled this extensively. The paradox doesn't apply to every case, but for households with meaningful longevity expectations and a long planning horizon, it's worth modeling rather than assuming.

    For faculty, the right share to annuitize tends to fall in a band: enough to make the floor reliable, not so much that flexibility disappears. Twenty to forty percent of investable assets is a frequent landing spot, depending on the rest of the picture.

    A composite scenario

    Consider a couple, both 64, both retiring at the end of the academic year. He is a humanities professor with thirty-two years at the same institution, all TIAA. She is a clinician educator at the same institution's medical school, with twenty-six years of TIAA balances plus a smaller defined benefit pension from a state system that participated in Social Security.

    Their combined TIAA balance is meaningful. Roughly half is in Traditional, much of it under RA contracts. They have a paid-off home, a college-funded daughter who is now a working adult, and a strong preference for not running out of money. Neither has a particularly strong bequest motive; their daughter is doing well, and their charitable intent is modest.

    Their guaranteed income at retirement, before any TIAA annuitization, will include both Social Security benefits and her pension. Together, those streams cover roughly 60 percent of their projected baseline expenses. The gap, the remaining 40 percent, is what their TIAA balances need to fill.

    For this couple, partial annuitization makes sense. Annuitizing enough Traditional to close the income gap, while leaving the variable accounts and a portion of Traditional in an IRA for flexibility, gives them a guaranteed income floor that covers essential expenses and a discretionary pool for everything else. The annuitized portion is in joint life form with a guaranteed period, so it continues paying as long as either spouse is alive, and a portion would pass on to their daughter if both died early in retirement. The long tenure in Traditional means the loyalty bonus is doing real work in the income calculation.

    Different facts, different answer. A couple with strong bequest motives, or with greater concern about long-term care costs, or with substantial outside assets, might annuitize less. A couple with weaker outside guaranteed income and greater longevity in the family would annuitize more. The framework is the same. The numbers are not.

    Questions that change the answer

    Before you decide, a few questions that genuinely change the answer.

    How much guaranteed income do you already have outside of TIAA? Social Security, a pension, rental income, a spouse's pension. The more you already have, the less you need from annuitization.

    Can you live on your RMDs plus Social Security and other recurring income? If your required distributions, plus Social Security, plus any pension, dividends, rental income, or part-time consulting, cover your annual spending comfortably, you may not need to annuitize at all. The Wait option becomes more compelling when the math already works without it.

    What is your view of longevity in your family? Annuitization rewards long lives. If both of your parents lived into their nineties, that matters.

    How important is leaving something to children or to charity? Annuitized assets pass on through the contract rather than the estate, and the form of contract you choose determines what's available to heirs. An IRA preserves more flexibility on the legacy side, including direct charitable beneficiary designations and Qualified Charitable Distributions during your lifetime.

    What is your relationship to managing money? Some people genuinely want to wake up at seventy-five and not think about portfolio decisions. Others find the management interesting. Both are legitimate.

    What are the institution-specific rules attached to your contracts? RA, GRA, SRA, GSRA, RC, and RCP contracts have different liquidity provisions, and the differences matter.

    What is the fee picture if you roll to an IRA? Compare the all-in cost of the 403(b), including any administrative and investment expenses, to the all-in cost of the IRA you would move to, including advisory fees, fund expenses, and platform costs. Then weigh that against the planning benefits: QCDs, broader investment choice, beneficiary flexibility, Roth conversion mechanics.

    The honest disclaimer

    This is the part where I most want to say: don't decide this on your own based on a podcast or a blog post, including this one. The TIAA decision interacts with your tax situation, your spouse's plans, your timeline, and your other assets in ways that are genuinely individual. A good advisor, or a good fee-only conversation, will save you more than it costs.

    Annuitization is also one of the few financial decisions that is, for practical purposes, irreversible. Once you have annuitized, you have annuitized. The asymmetry of regret matters here. Underannuitizing can usually be corrected later. Overannuitizing usually cannot.

    Ready to Talk?

    Schedule a 30-Minute Discussion. We'll review your income, benefits, retirement contributions, and portfolio structure so your next steps are rooted in clarity.

    https://app.greminders.com/c/danfagan

    Daniel Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF® Managing Partner | Sr. Wealth Management Advisor 110 Washington Ave., 3rd Floor, North Haven, CT 06473 Office: 475.234.5965 | Cell: 860.748.2552 dan.fagan@radiantwm.com

    About Dan

    Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience, including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor, Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most.

    This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Individual circumstances vary. Please consult qualified professionals for advice specific to your situation. Advisory services are offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure. TIAA Traditional is a fixed annuity product issued by Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America (TIAA). All guarantees are subject to TIAA's claims-paying ability. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.

    Sources and Further Reading

    Yaari, M.E. (1965). "Uncertain Lifetime, Life Insurance, and the Theory of the Consumer." Review of Economic Studies, 32(2), 137-150.

    Mitchell, O.S., Poterba, J.M., Warshawsky, M.J., and Brown, J.R. (1999). "New Evidence on the Money's Worth of Individual Annuities." American Economic Review, 89(5), 1299-1318.

    Davidoff, T., Brown, J.R., and Diamond, P.A. (2005). "Annuities and Individual Welfare." American Economic Review, 95(5), 1573-1590.

    Brown, J.R. (2007). "Rational and Behavioral Perspectives on the Role of Annuities in Retirement Planning." NBER Working Paper No. 13537. https://www.nber.org/papers/w13537

    Pfau, W.D. Safety-First Retirement Planning (Retirement Researcher Media, 2019) and related work in the Journal of Financial Planning.

    TIAA Actuarial Department. Study of TIAA standard payout annuity, December 2020. Basis for the 22.5% lifetime income advantage for long-tenured Traditional contributors.

    TIAA Institute. Research on TIAA Traditional, annuitization decisions, and faculty retirement income. https://www.tiaainstitute.org

    Department of Labor. Prohibited Transaction Exemption 2020-02 and related guidance on fiduciary obligations for rollover recommendations.


    About Dan Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience, including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor, Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most.

    This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Individual circumstances vary. Please consult qualified professionals for advice specific to your situation. Advisory services are offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure.