← Insights

    Sequence of Returns Risk: Two Professors, $400,000 Apart

    If you are a faculty member who has spent decades contributing to a 403(b), you have probably been told that what matters most is how much you save and how your investments perform over time. Both are true during your working years. But the moment you retire and start drawing income, a different force takes over, one most people have never heard of until it has already done its damage. It is called sequence of returns risk, and for TIAA participants and other faculty retirees, it can be the difference between a plan that lasts and one that runs dry. Here is what it looks like in real life.

    Let me tell you about two professors I'll call David and Margaret.

    Both spent their careers at respected research universities. Both earned similar salaries. Both contributed the maximum to their 403(b) plans for decades. Both retired with approximately $1 million in their retirement accounts.

    David retired in March 2000.

    Margaret retired in March 2003.

    Three years apart. Same credentials. Same planning. Same accumulation strategies.

    Radically different outcomes.

    What David Experienced

    David retired at the absolute peak of the dot-com bubble. He'd watched his portfolio grow spectacularly through the late 1990s, and his final year before retirement had been his best ever.

    He felt confident. Maybe a little lucky.

    Then the market turned.

    In 2000, the S&P 500 lost 10.1%. In 2001, it lost another 13%. In 2002, it fell 22.1%. David's million-dollar portfolio dropped to roughly $600,000, and he was withdrawing $50,000 per year throughout this decline.

    According to Britannica Money's analysis of actual market returns: "If you had retired into that bear market while taking $50,000 a year, you'd have $687,927 left at the beginning of 2002."

    But David wasn't done. The 2008 financial crisis hit when he was eight years into retirement. His depleted portfolio took another 37% hit in 2008, compounding on a base that had never recovered.

    David ran out of money before he ran out of life.

    What Margaret Experienced

    Margaret also had $1 million. She also planned to withdraw $50,000 per year.

    But Margaret retired in March 2003, near the bottom of the bear market.

    The S&P 500 gained 26.4% in 2003. It gained 9% in 2004, 3% in 2005, and 13.6% in 2006. By the time the 2008 crisis hit, Margaret's portfolio had grown enough that even a 37% drop was survivable.

    Same withdrawal rate. Same market over the long term. Completely different trajectory.

    Margaret's money lasted through her lifetime, and left something for her heirs.

    The Math That Explains Everything

    This phenomenon has a name: sequence of returns risk.

    According to a landmark academic study published on SSRN by De Jong and Robinson, "A Case Study in Sequence Risk: A 20-Year Retrospective on the Impact of the 2000–2002 and 2007–2009 Bear Markets on Retirement Nest Egg Sustainability," the timing of returns matters far more than their average.

    A detailed analysis from AG Wealth Management using actual S&P 500 returns from 2000-2020 shows:

    Investor 1 (David's scenario): After 20 years with annual withdrawals, ending balance approximately $508,433.

    Investor 2 (reversed sequence): After 20 years with identical withdrawals, ending balance approximately $2,443,168.

    Same average returns. Same withdrawals. Difference of nearly $2 million.

    What You Can Do About It

    Sequence risk can't be eliminated, but it can be managed:

    1. Build a cash buffer. Having 2-3 years of expenses in stable value or short-term bonds means you won't have to sell equities during a downturn.

    2. Consider flexible withdrawal strategies. Reducing withdrawals during down years can dramatically improve portfolio survival.

    3. Reduce concentration before retirement. If your portfolio is heavily weighted toward the Magnificent Seven, the five years before retirement are the time to rebalance, not after.

    4. Consider partial annuitization. Converting a portion of your portfolio to guaranteed lifetime income removes sequence risk for that portion. For faculty with TIAA Traditional, this is worth understanding well before you retire, since the contract rules govern when and how you can convert.

    5. Delay Social Security if possible. Each year you delay past full retirement age (up to 70) increases your benefit by 8%.

    The Bottom Line

    David and Margaret worked the same careers. Saved the same amounts. Retired with the same portfolios.

    The only difference was timing, and preparation.

    You can't control when the market decides to crash. But you can control how exposed you are when it does.

    That's not timing the market. That's understanding the math.

    📅 Schedule a Call: https://app.greminders.com/c/danfagan 📧 dan.fagan@radiantwm.com

    About Dan

    Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience, including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor, Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most.

    Advisory services offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure.

    This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Investing involves risk and possible loss of principal capital. No advice may be rendered by NewEdge Advisors unless a client service agreement is in place.

    California Residents: We take protecting your data and privacy very seriously. As of January 1, 2020, the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) provides additional rights to residents of California. You may view our data privacy statement or exercise your rights here: Do not sell my personal information.

    References

    SSRN Academic Study: De Jong & Robinson, "A Case Study in Sequence Risk" (April 2021). https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3832165

    Britannica Money: 2000-2001 S&P returns: -10.1%, -13%. Portfolio scenario analysis. https://www.britannica.com/money/sequence-of-returns-risk

    AG Wealth Management: 2000-2020 case study: $508K vs $2.44M with same average returns. https://www.agwealthm.com/post/understanding-sequence-of-return-risk-the-hidden-threat-to-retirement-and-early-retirement

    Charles Schwab: Detailed analysis of early vs. late declines; flexible withdrawal strategies. https://www.schwab.com/learn/story/timing-matters-understanding-sequence-returns-risk

    New York Life: Accumulation vs. distribution phase analysis. https://www.newyorklife.com/articles/sequence-returns-risk

    Simplicity OID: "Fragile decade" concept; secular market cycles. https://simplicityoid.com/sequence-of-returns-risk/

    T. Rowe Price: Target date investing implications; historical analysis 1925-2020. https://www.troweprice.com/content/dam/retirement-plan-services/pdfs/insights/investment-insights/A_Different_Perspective_on_Sequence-of-Returns_Risk.pdf

    TIAA: Major retirement risks framework. https://www.tiaa.org/public/pdf/major_risks_in_retirement.pdf

    U.S. Bank: Retirement timing strategies. https://www.usbank.com/retirement-planning/financial-perspectives/sequence-of-returns-risk-impact-when-to-retire.html


    About Dan Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience, including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor, Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most.

    This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Individual circumstances vary. Please consult qualified professionals for advice specific to your situation. Advisory services are offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure.