← Insights

    Roth Conversions for Professors: The Mistakes That Cost the Most

    Why the smartest people on campus get the math wrong — and the windows when converting actually works

    If you have a 403(b) at TIAA or Fidelity, you’ve probably wondered whether to convert some of it to a Roth. The strategy gets recommended constantly, in faculty lounges and on retirement forums. The most expensive mistake academics make with it comes down to one misunderstood number: what a conversion actually costs in tax.

    Here’s the question that starts more bad conversion decisions than any other:

    “I’m in the 22% tax bracket, so a Roth conversion costs me 22%, right?”

    Dr. Michael Torres, an economics professor, asked me this last month. An economics professor. If he’s getting this wrong, what chance does everyone else have?

    “Actually,” I said, pulling up his tax return, “that $50,000 conversion you’re considering? It’ll cost you 24% to 32% in taxes, not 22%.”

    His face went pale. “But I’m in the 22% bracket…”

    Here’s the painful irony: the smarter you are, the more likely you are to make this mistake. Why? Because smart people understand tax brackets. They read the IRS tables. They know their marginal rate. They think they have it figured out.

    But they’re solving the wrong equation.

    The Intelligence Trap

    Professors, doctors, engineers — my smartest clients make the biggest Roth conversion errors. They:

    •             Overthink the simple (tax brackets)

    •             Oversimplify the complex (how taxes actually stack)

    •             Focus on optimization (maximum conversions)

    •             Miss the big picture (marginal cost vs. average savings)

    Michael had spreadsheets modeling market returns to the decimal point but didn’t realize his “22% conversion” would actually cost 31.5%.

    Smart people know just enough to be dangerous.

    Tax Bracket vs. Tax Rate vs. Conversion Cost

    Here’s what Michael — and most intelligent people — get wrong:

    Your tax bracket ≠ Your tax rate ≠ Your conversion cost

    With his $165,000 salary, Michael was indeed in the 22% bracket. But here’s his actual 2025 tax picture:

    •             Average rate: 15.9% (what he actually pays on all income)

    •             Marginal rate: 22% (what he pays on the last dollar)

    •             Conversion rate: 24–32% (what the Roth conversion actually costs)

    Why the difference? He’s only $41,050 away from jumping to the 24% bracket.

    The Stacking Problem

    Here’s where Michael lost a fortune: Roth conversions don’t replace your income — they stack on top.

    Michael’s Real Conversion Cost:

     

    Without Conversion

    With $50k Conversion

    Income

    $176,000

    $226,000

    Total tax

    $30,750

    $46,500

    Effective rate

    17.5%

    20.6%

    Actual conversion cost: $15,750 (31.5%!)

    The conversion didn’t just get taxed — it pushed his other income into higher brackets. His “22% conversion” actually cost him 31.5%.

    The Real Math: Conversion Cost vs. Retirement Average Rate

    Here’s the comparison that actually matters — and that almost everyone gets wrong:

    What You Pay to Convert: Your marginal rate (every dollar at the highest rate) What You Save: Your average rate in retirement (RMDs fill lower brackets first)

    Let me show you why this destroys most conversion strategies:

    Professor Williams at Peak Earnings (Age 55):

    •             Income: $250,000

    •             Marginal rate for conversion: 32%

    •             Converts $100,000: Pays $32,000 in taxes

    Professor Williams in Retirement (Age 75):

    •             Social Security: $45,000

    •             RMDs: $120,000

    •             Total income: $165,000

    •             Tax on $165,000: $26,288

    •             Average tax rate: 15.9%

    Williams paid 32% to avoid 15.9%. He lost $16,100 on that $100,000 conversion!

    This is the mistake smart people make: they compare marginal to marginal instead of marginal to average.

    The RMD Reality Check

    “But what about huge RMDs?” Michael asked. “Won’t those push me into high brackets?”

    Even with massive RMDs, your average rate rarely exceeds your peak marginal rate:

    $200,000 RMD Scenario:

    •             Social Security: $45,000

    •             RMDs: $200,000

    •             Total income: $245,000

    •             Total tax: ~$45,000

    •             Average rate: 18.4%

    To justify converting at 32%, your average rate in retirement needs to exceed 32%. That requires RMDs over $400,000 annually — a portfolio worth $10+ million.

    The Conversion Decision Matrix

    Your Current Marginal Rate

    Convert Only If Retirement AVERAGE Rate Exceeds:

    37%

    37% (essentially never)

    35%

    35% (extremely rare)

    32%

    32% (only with $10M+ portfolios)

    24%

    24% (possible with poor planning)

    22%

    22% (reasonable for large portfolios)

    12%

    12% (almost always convert)

    10%

    10% (always convert)

    This is why converting at peak earnings is usually insane — you’re paying marginal rates to avoid average rates.

    The Roth 403(b) Trap

    “Forget conversions,” Michael said. “I’ll just contribute to my Roth 403(b) instead.”

    Same problem, different wrapper. At his income level, the Roth 403(b) was costing him 22–24% in lost tax deductions to avoid a 15.9% average rate in retirement.

    Smart people love Roth 403(b)s because they seem sophisticated. “Tax-free growth!” But they’re paying premium prices for future benefits they’ll never need.

    When Roth Conversions Work for Professors: The Golden Windows

    After seeing the true math, Michael redesigned everything. We identified his conversion sweet spots:

    Age 64–66: Phased Retirement

    •             Drop to half-time teaching

    •             Income falls to $82,000

    •             Marginal rate: 12%

    •             Convert $40,000 annually at 12% (not 31.5%!)

    •             Retirement average rate: 15.9%

    •             Now he’s winning: 12% vs. 15.9%

    Age 67–69: The Gap Years

    •             Fully retired, before Social Security

    •             Only investment income (~$40,000)

    •             Can convert $55,000 at 12% marginal

    •             Another $40,000 at 22% marginal

    •             Blended conversion rate: 16%

    •             Still beats his 18–20% retirement average rate

    Total savings from waiting: $67,000

    The Conversion Sweet Spots

    After modeling hundreds of academic retirements, here’s when conversions actually work:

    The Sabbatical Strategy. Drop from 32% marginal to 22% or lower.

    The Phased Retirement Play. Half income = half the marginal rate = profitable conversions.

    The Gap Years Goldmine. No earned income = maximum space at minimum rates.

    The Market Downturn Gift. Convert more shares for same dollar amount when markets drop 20%+.

    Your Conversion Calculator

    Three steps to avoid Michael’s mistake:

    1.          Calculate your marginal rate NOW (what conversions cost)

    2.          Project your AVERAGE rate in retirement (what you’re avoiding)

    3.          Only convert if #2 > #1

    Remember: Your conversion gets taxed at marginal rates but saves you average rates. This gap is why most conversions fail.

    The Bottom Line

    Michael teaches economics, yet he nearly converted at 31.5% to avoid a 15.9% average rate — a $67,000 mistake.

    Why? Because smart people compare marginal to marginal. They optimize for the wrong variable. They solve complex equations but miss simple truths.

    Your tax bracket isn’t your tax rate. Your conversion cost is your marginal rate. Your savings is your average rate. And that difference? It’s everything.

    Most professors convert at peak earnings (expensive marginal rates) instead of strategic windows (cheap marginal rates). They’re not tax-planning — they’re donating to the Treasury.

    The secret isn’t whether to convert. It’s when.

    And for most high-earning professors? That “when” is never during peak earnings. It’s in the windows when your marginal rate drops below your retirement average rate.

    Smart people make the worst Roth conversion mistakes because they’re confident in their understanding. But confidence without complete information is expensive.

    Don’t be smart. Be right.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What tax rate do I actually pay on a Roth conversion? Your marginal rate, and possibly higher. A conversion stacks on top of your existing income, so every converted dollar is taxed at your highest rate. A large conversion can push dollars into the next bracket. Your average tax rate only matters on the savings side, not the cost side.

    When is the best time for a professor to do Roth conversions? The windows when your marginal rate drops below your projected average rate in retirement: sabbaticals, phased retirement at reduced income, and especially the “gap years” between full retirement and the start of Social Security and RMDs. Peak earning years are usually the worst time.

    Can I convert my TIAA 403(b) to a Roth while I’m still working? Often, yes — many university plans, including TIAA-recordkept plans, permit in-plan Roth conversions if the employer has adopted the feature, and some permit conversions of rollover-eligible balances. The rules vary by plan and by TIAA contract type, so check with your benefits office before assuming either way. Whether you can is a plan question. Whether you should is the marginal-vs-average math above.

    Should I just use a Roth 403(b) instead of converting? It’s the same equation in a different wrapper. Contributing to a Roth 403(b) at peak earnings means giving up a deduction at your marginal rate to avoid taxes at your retirement average rate. For high earners that trade usually goes the wrong way. The Roth 403(b) tends to make more sense in lower-income years.

    Do Roth conversions affect Medicare premiums? They can. A conversion raises your modified adjusted gross income, which can trigger higher Medicare premiums (IRMAA) two years later once you’re 63 or older. It’s one more reason conversion timing deserves real modeling rather than a rule of thumb.

    (Internal links for this piece: “Your TIAA Options at Retirement: A Decision Guide for Professors” · “What Bonds Did in 2022 — and What TIAA Traditional Did Instead” · phased retirement post [when live] · payroll & tax threshold checklist [when live])

    Ready to talk? Schedule a Roth conversion analysis. We’ll calculate your current marginal rate, project your retirement average rate, and identify if (and when) conversions make sense — so you convert smart, not expensive.

    Daniel Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF® Managing Partner | Sr. Wealth Management Advisor A: 110 Washington Ave., 3rd Floor, North Haven, CT 06473 P: (475) 234-5965 | M: (860) 748-2552 E: dan.fagan@radiantwm.com

    About Dan Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience — including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor — Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most. He is the author of Getting to Emeritus: A Financial Guide for Faculty at Every Career Stage (Johns Hopkins University Press, Summer 2026).

    Advisory services offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure.

    This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. Consult your investment, tax, or legal advisor for guidance specific to your situation. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Investing involves risk and possible loss of principal capital. No advice may be rendered by NewEdge Advisors unless a client service agreement is in place.

    This case study is hypothetical in nature and is provided for illustrative purposes. The case study presented is not indicative of all client experiences with Radiant Wealth Management. Each client has unique circumstances. Case studies presented should not be interpreted as a guarantee of future performance or success.


    About Dan Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience, including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor, Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most.

    This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Individual circumstances vary. Please consult qualified professionals for advice specific to your situation. Advisory services are offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure.