Most plans don’t fail slowly — they fail the first time reality deviates. The three failure points professors should test before they matter.
If you’re within a decade of retirement, your plan has probably passed every review it’s ever had: reasonable assumptions, defensible averages, tidy projections from TIAA or your own spreadsheet. What it probably hasn’t faced is the question that decides outcomes: what happens the first time something goes wrong? This piece walks through the three places retirement plans break under stress, and what the plans that survive have in common.
Most retirement plans don’t fail slowly.
They fail the first time reality deviates meaningfully from the spreadsheet.
On paper, many plans look sound. The assumptions are reasonable. The averages are defensible. The projections are tidy.
Then stress arrives.
A market downturn. An unexpected retirement date. A health issue. A period of higher spending than planned.
And suddenly, a plan that looked durable reveals where it was fragile all along.
What Stress Actually Does
Stress doesn’t just reduce portfolio values. It exposes hidden assumptions.
Under stress, plans fail not because returns are lower than expected, but because flexibility disappears.
Spending that was assumed to be adjustable turns out to be fixed. Risk that was assumed to be tolerable becomes emotionally unbearable. Timelines that were assumed to be flexible suddenly aren’t.
The spreadsheet never modeled that.
The First Failure Point: Rigid Spending
Most plans assume a stable, inflation-adjusted withdrawal rate.
Real life doesn’t behave that way.
Spending often rises early in retirement, not later. Travel, home projects, helping family. Then healthcare costs arrive unevenly, not smoothly.
When markets decline early and spending can’t adjust, withdrawals do more damage than expected. Not because they’re reckless, but because they’re rigid.
Stress turns reasonable assumptions into compounding pressure.
The Second Failure Point: Emotional Capacity
Risk tolerance on a questionnaire is not the same as risk tolerance under stress.
Many people believe they can tolerate volatility because they did during accumulation. But accumulation volatility is abstract. Retirement volatility is personal.
Seeing balances decline while actively withdrawing changes behavior. Even disciplined investors second-guess themselves.
Plans that rely on “staying the course” without acknowledging this reality are brittle.
The Third Failure Point: Timing Compression
Stress shortens timelines.
A professor planning to retire at 67 may suddenly face a buyout offer at 62. Or a department closure. Or a health issue that makes continued work unrealistic.
A market decline close to retirement compresses recovery time and forces decisions sooner than expected. Choices that once felt optional become mandatory.
This is where average-return planning breaks down completely.
Why This Isn’t About Better Forecasting
This isn’t a call for more precise predictions.
It’s a reminder that planning works best when it anticipates deviation, not perfection.
Durable plans are not those with the best assumptions. They are the ones with room to absorb surprise.
They acknowledge uncertainty without being paralyzed by it.
What Holds Up Under Stress
Plans that survive real stress tend to share a few structural traits.
They separate short-term spending from long-term growth so near-term needs aren’t dependent on market cooperation. They allow spending to flex without derailing the entire strategy. They reduce reliance on perfect timing. And they explicitly account for the fact that behavior matters when the stakes are real.
These are not tactical tweaks. They are design choices.
The Bottom Line
Retirement plans don’t usually fail because they were careless.
They fail because they were built for average conditions in a world that delivers extremes.
The goal isn’t to design a plan that works only when nothing goes wrong.
It’s to design one that holds together when something inevitably does.
That’s the difference between optimization and resilience.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a retirement plan stress test? It’s the practice of running your plan through the uncomfortable scenarios rather than the average ones: poor returns in the first years of withdrawals, an earlier-than-planned retirement date, uneven healthcare costs, spending that can’t flex. The goal is to find the weak points while there’s still time to fix them.
Why do most retirement plans fail? Rarely because of carelessness. The common failure points are structural: spending that turns out to be rigid when markets decline, risk tolerance that evaporates once withdrawals begin, and timelines that compress — a buyout offer, a department closure, a health issue — before the portfolio has recovered.
What makes a retirement plan resilient? Separation of near-term spending from long-term growth, room for spending to flex, reduced dependence on timing, and an honest account of how real people behave when balances fall. These are design choices made in advance, not adjustments made in a crisis.
When should a professor stress test their plan? In the decade before retirement — while contributions still matter, dates are still movable, and there’s time to restructure. The worst time to discover a plan’s fragility is when a buyout offer lands on your desk with a 60-day decision window.
(Internal links for this piece: “The Average Returns Myth: The Retirement Math Professors Miss” · “Five to Ten Years From Retirement? Here’s What to Protect First” · “Phased Retirement for Professors: The Math Behind the Smartest Year You’ll Ever Work” · “What Bonds Did in 2022 — and What TIAA Traditional Did Instead”)
Sources & Further Reading
Wade D. Pfau. Retirement Planning Guidebook and peer-reviewed research on sequence risk, spending flexibility, and retirement income sustainability. https://retirementresearcher.com
William P. Bengen (1994). Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data. Journal of Financial Planning. https://www.onefpa.org/journal/Pages/Determining%20Withdrawal%20Rates%20Using%20Historical%20Data.aspx
Michael Kitces. Research on retirement stress testing, behavioral risk, and spending flexibility. https://www.kitces.com/blog
Morningstar Investment Management. Blanchett, Benz et al., research on retirement spending patterns and early-retirement vulnerability. https://www.morningstar.com/retirement
TIAA Institute. Major Risks in Retirement. https://www.tiaainstitute.org/publication/major-risks-retirement
Vanguard Research. From Assets to Income. https://corporate.vanguard.com/content/corporatesite/us/en/corp/articles/from-assets-to-income.html
Ready to talk? Schedule a 30-minute discussion (Zoom or phone). We’ll review your income, benefits, retirement contributions, and legacy planning options so your next steps are rooted in clarity.
Daniel Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF® Managing Partner | Sr. Wealth Management Advisor A: 110 Washington Ave., 3rd Floor, North Haven, CT 06473 P: (475) 234-5965 | M: (860) 748-2552 E: dan.fagan@radiantwm.com
About Dan Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience, including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor, Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most. He is the author of Getting to Emeritus: A Financial Guide for Faculty at Every Career Stage (Johns Hopkins University Press, Summer 2026).
Advisory services are offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure. This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Investing involves risk and possible loss of principal capital. No advice may be rendered by NewEdge Advisors unless a client service agreement is in place.
Education only. We do not offer tax advice. Please consult your CPA.
About Dan Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience, including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor, Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most.
This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Individual circumstances vary. Please consult qualified professionals for advice specific to your situation. Advisory services are offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure.
