← Insights

    Why Some Retirement Income Plans Bend and Others Break

    Most retirement plans run on a single engine: the portfolio. That works right up until it doesn't — an early bear market, a health event, a retirement date that moves without asking. Here's the design flaw hiding in otherwise careful plans, and how income design fixes it before markets get a vote.

    Ask people what flexibility means in retirement and you'll usually hear a version of the same answer: spend more when markets are good, cut back when they aren't.

    That's part of it. It's not the important part.

    Real flexibility is structural. It's built into how income is generated, not just how money is spent. And that distinction — the engine versus the throttle — is where a lot of otherwise careful retirement plans quietly fall short.

    The one-engine problem

    Most retirement income plans run on a single engine: the portfolio. Every dollar of spending traces back to the same pool of invested assets, and all of the plan's flexibility lives on the spending side. Markets cooperate, you spend comfortably. Markets don't, you cut.

    Under normal conditions, that structure looks fine. Under stress, it shows its limits — and it tends to show them at the worst possible moment:

    •          Markets fall early in retirement. Withdrawals taken in a down market do disproportionate damage, because every dollar sold at depressed prices is a dollar that never participates in the recovery. Advisors call it sequence-of-returns risk. Retirees experience it as watching the math get worse while doing everything right.

    •          Health changes the budget. Spending cuts are the one-engine plan's only defense, and health costs are the category of spending that doesn't negotiate. The moment the plan most needs you to spend less can be the moment life requires you to spend more.

    •          Retirement arrives sooner than planned. A shorter accumulation runway, a longer distribution one, and no time to rebuild. The date isn't always yours to choose.

    A plan whose only adjustment mechanism is spending less is a plan that depends on the market's cooperation. Over a 30- or 40-year retirement, that's a lot of cooperation to count on.

    The second engine

    A more durable design starts by separating two kinds of income: income you must have, and income you'd like markets to provide.

    The first step isn't a product decision at all. It's an inventory. Go through the budget and split it into essential expenses — housing, food, insurance, health care, the bills that arrive whether or not the S&P had a good year — and discretionary ones: travel, gifts, the spending that makes retirement enjoyable rather than merely solvent.

    Then map your guaranteed income sources against the essential number. Social Security. A pension, if you have one. And, for many academics, the lifetime income options already embedded in retirement plans they've been contributing to for decades.

    If guaranteed sources cover essential expenses — or come close — something important happens to the rest of the portfolio: its job changes. It's no longer responsible for keeping the lights on every month. It can take risk more intentionally, ride out bad markets without forced selling, and fund the discretionary life on a flexible schedule. Researchers call this a floor-and-upside structure: secure the floor first, then expose the rest to growth.

    This is where converting a portion of assets into guaranteed lifetime income enters the conversation — not as an all-or-nothing decision, and not as a replacement for investing. As a way to reduce how much has to go right at the same time.

    The behavioral research backs up what most people feel instinctively here. When retirees do choose lifetime income, they strongly prefer converting part of their assets over all of them — because a partial approach secures the income floor while leaving liquid assets intact. It doesn't eliminate flexibility. It relocates it.

    Where this shows up for academics

    For faculty and physicians with long careers in academic retirement systems, this conversation usually intersects with TIAA — particularly the traditional and lifetime income options built into long-standing plans.

    Used thoughtfully, those structures can reduce pressure on the remaining portfolio, let spending decisions flex without fear, lower the emotional load during market stress, and improve durability when retirement timing shifts.

    The mistake isn't using them or avoiding them. The mistake is treating them as either mandatory or irrelevant — annuitizing everything because a payout illustration looked reassuring, or ignoring decades of accumulated guarantees because the word “annuity” carries baggage. The right amount of floor is a planning question, not a product question, and it's different for every household.

    (If you're in Connecticut's state higher-ed system, there's a separate, non-optional reason lifetime income may be on your retirement checklist — a $10,000 annuity requirement tied to retiree health coverage. I've written a full piece on that rule, publishing soon.)

    Flexibility is about reducing forced decisions

    Here's the frame I'd keep, whatever the specific tools turn out to be:

    The most damaging retirement decisions are usually the forced ones. Selling assets at the wrong time because income was needed. Cutting spending when health demanded the opposite. Abandoning a long-term strategy under stress because there was no other lever to pull.

    Plans with multiple income sources create choices. Plans with one create pressure. A second engine doesn't eliminate risk — nothing does. It reduces the number of things that have to go right at the same time.

    That difference matters more than most people expect, and it matters most in exactly the years when nothing else is going according to plan.

    The bottom line

    Flexibility in retirement is not just about spending less when markets disappoint. It's about designing income so markets don't dictate every decision.

    For many retirees — especially those with long careers in academic systems, where the building blocks are often already sitting inside the plan — a secure income floor paired with an intentionally invested portfolio is a quiet but powerful way to build resilience without giving up control.

    It's not about choosing guarantees over growth. It's about giving your plan more than one way to work.

    Questions about how your own income picture is built? That's what I'm here for. You can grab a time on my calendar — no pressure, just clarity.

    Dan

    Sources & further reading

    •          Michael Kitces, Behavioral Biases and the Hierarchy of Retirement Needs — kitces.com/blog/hierarchy-retirement-income-needs-and-mental-accounting — on why retirees prefer partial lifetime income to all-or-nothing, and the mental accounting behind income floors

    •          Wade D. Pfau, Safety-First Retirement Planning and related research at retirementresearcher.com

    •          Vanguard Research, From Assets to Income: A Goals-Based Approach to Retirement Spending — corporate.vanguard.com

    •          TIAA Institute, research on guaranteed income and retirement security — tiaainstitute.org

    This article is educational and general in nature. It is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice, and it does not account for any individual's specific circumstances. Guarantees are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuer. Current as of July 2026.

    Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®

    Managing Partner, Sr. Wealth Management Advisor, Radiant Wealth Management

    dan.fagan@radiantwm.com  |  Office: 475.234.5965  |  Cell: 860.748.2552

    Scheduling: app.greminders.com/c/danfagan

    Radiant Wealth Management is a fee-only practice serving faculty, physicians, and academic professionals.


    About Dan Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience, including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor, Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most.

    This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Individual circumstances vary. Please consult qualified professionals for advice specific to your situation. Advisory services are offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure.