← Insights

    When the News and the Market Disagree: A Guide for Faculty and Physicians Near Retirement

    Every few years, the world produces a moment when the headlines say one thing and your portfolio says another. We are in one of those moments right now. Here's how to read both signals without letting either one make your decisions for you, and the three questions worth asking about your own plan while the moment is still live.

     Consider the moment we're in as I write this.

    Since February 28, when U.S. and Israeli strikes on Iran began, the Strait of Hormuz — the waterway that carried roughly a fifth of the world's seaborne oil and gas — has been severely disrupted, with only limited tanker traffic getting through. The International Energy Agency is calling it the largest oil supply shock in the history of global energy markets. Oil moved above $100 a barrel this week. Prior talks have collapsed. The historical parallel on everyone's lips is 1973.

    And yet the market, at least today, is up.

    That's not a malfunction. Markets are reacting to what might happen next, not to what just happened — pricing the odds of resolution while the crisis is still on the front page. If you're within ten years of retirement, the gap between what the headlines say and what your account balance does isn't a flaw in the system. It's the system. Learning to read both signals, without letting either one make your decisions for you, is the central challenge of investing near retirement — and this moment is as clean a live example as markets ever provide.

    Why markets don't move the way the news does

    Markets are forward-looking. By the time a geopolitical event feels significant enough to act on, markets have usually priced in some version of it, and they begin pricing the resolution while the crisis is still on the front page.

    The research here is consistent. Caldara and Iacoviello, whose Geopolitical Risk Index has become the field's standard measure, found that stock returns experience a meaningful but short-lived drop in response to geopolitical shocks. The initial reaction is real; the persistent effect is smaller than most investors expect. J.P. Morgan's analysis of more than 80 years of major geopolitical events, from World War II through Ukraine, reached the same conclusion from a different direction: markets tend to recover faster than the underlying crises resolve.

    None of this means the current risk isn't real. It means the market is making a bet about resolution, not a statement about current conditions. This week's price action is evidence of exactly that: oil easing off its highs, equities rising, investors leaning toward the possibility that talks resume rather than escalate. The event feels permanent. If history is any guide, the market's reaction usually isn't.

    The seriousness deserves stating plainly, though. Roughly 20 percent of the world's seaborne oil and gas exports passed through that strait before February 28, and the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas has modeled that a closure removing that supply could lower global real GDP growth by nearly 3 percentage points on an annualized basis this quarter. The 1973 analogy has real limits — the U.S. energy position today is fundamentally different, and we are the world's largest LNG exporter — but the portfolio lessons of that era are worth sitting with.

    The part that should actually worry you: sequence

    Here's the piece of this that deserves your attention far more than any single headline, and it's best told through a hypothetical grounded in real market history.

    Two professors retire in the early 1970s with identical savings and identical allocations. The first retires in early 1973, at what feels like a stable and prosperous moment. The second retires in early 1976, after the worst of that era's disruption has passed. Between 1973 and 1974, the S&P 500 falls roughly 48 percent and doesn't fully recover until 1980. The professor who retired in 1973 and began withdrawing immediately faces a completely different math problem than the one who retired three years later — with the same long-term average return. The sequence of the losses relative to the start of withdrawals is what mattered, not the eventual recovery.

    That mechanism, sequence-of-returns risk, operates in every major disruption. It's the reason a moment like this one deserves attention from anyone near retirement even when the day's number is green — and it's the reason the right response is structural rather than reactive.

    Four kinds of risk, four different responses

    Not every risk in the current picture deserves the same response or the same time horizon. When clients call in moments like this, I sort what's happening into four categories:

    Geopolitical risk — the strikes, the strait, the escalation — tends to be sharp, severe in the short term, and more contained than it feels. History says markets absorb these over months, not years, unless they fundamentally alter the global economic order.

    Trade risk — tariffs, supply-chain restructuring, decoupling — moves slower but cuts deeper. These forces change the cost basis of entire industries and persist for years. They're worth watching in your portfolio for sector concentration, not for making rapid moves.

    Structural risk deserves a longer conversation if you work in higher education. In my practice, I hear regularly from faculty about AI-driven efficiency reviews — administrative consolidations, course redesign conversations, early-retirement incentives that feel less optional than they're presented. Whether this accelerates or plateaus is genuinely uncertain, but the pressure on institutional budgets is showing up in real conversations. For someone planning to work until 67, the question AI introduces is not whether your job disappears. It's whether your institution will look the same in eight years, and whether you'll have enough financial independence that the timing of your exit is a choice rather than something that gets made for you.

    Inflation risk connects the other three. A Hormuz disruption that keeps oil elevated for six to twelve months changes inflation expectations everywhere — not just at the pump, but in healthcare supply chains, in university operating budgets, and in the real purchasing power of what your 403(b) will buy twenty years from now.

    Three questions worth asking about your plan

    The research on investor behavior during geopolitical stress is consistent and not flattering: MSCI found that high geopolitical-risk periods bring lower equity returns and higher volatility, and that investors who react by shifting allocations typically underperform those who don't. A portfolio that needs to change because of a war was the wrong portfolio before the war. The useful work isn't reacting to this event — it's testing whether your plan was built for the next one. Three questions get at that:

    First: does my plan separate healthcare inflation from general inflation? Healthcare inflation has outpaced CPI for decades, and healthcare supply chains run on energy. A $15,000 annual healthcare expense growing at 5 percent becomes nearly $40,000 in twenty years. If your plan models one inflation rate for everything, it's probably understating the risk that compounds most directly against you.

    Second: do I have 12 to 24 months of spending accessible without selling equities? This is the first bucket of a basic liquidity strategy, and for TIAA participants it hides a trap worth naming precisely. TIAA Traditional held under a Retirement Annuity contract — the most common contract type for faculty who enrolled before 2000 — is not immediately accessible. It distributes over roughly ten years through the Transfer Payout Annuity. An $800,000 Traditional balance under an RA contract isn't $800,000 you can reach; it's roughly $80,000 a year for a decade. The money is real. The access is not immediate. I have sat with clients who felt financially secure because of a large Traditional balance and then discovered, in a volatile market, that they had no genuine liquidity bucket — their near-term spending depended on selling equities at exactly the wrong moment. That is sequence risk made concrete. If most of your assets sit in TIAA Traditional under an RA contract, accessible cash reserves need to be built before retirement, as a structural decision made when you have time and options.

    Third: has my plan been stress-tested against a prolonged inflationary environment, not just a market decline? The 2022 scenario is the model: stocks down 18 percent, bonds down 13 percent, a 60/40 portfolio losing roughly 16 percent in a single year. That wasn't a geopolitical event; it was an inflation event, and this era keeps producing the ingredients for another one. Ask to see the output — not reassurance, the actual numbers.

    What protects you isn't prediction

    I've been in this work for over thirty years, including seventeen inside TIAA, and the hardest part of a moment like this spring isn't the analysis. It's the sustained discomfort of holding a long-term plan while the world feels genuinely uncertain.

    The faculty and physicians I work with are trained to think carefully under pressure. That's a real advantage, until it isn't — intelligence doesn't protect you from behavioral bias. If anything, it gives your anxiety better vocabulary.

    What protects you is structure: a plan built to absorb events like this rather than one that assumed they wouldn't happen. This moment is a live test. If you're not sure whether your plan would pass it — or whether it was ever tested at all — that's worth finding out now, while markets are still functioning, the options are open, and you have time to make deliberate choices. That's always the better moment. Not after the fact.

    If you're weighing what role guaranteed income should play in that structure, I've written about the counterintuitive power of partial annuitization — a piece that pairs naturally with this one.

    Questions about whether your own plan would pass the test? That's what I'm here for. You can grab a time on my calendar — no pressure, just clarity.

    Dan

     

    Sources

    •     Caldara, D., & Iacoviello, M. (2022). Measuring Geopolitical Risk. American Economic Review, 112(4).

    •     Congressional Research Service (March 2026). Iran Conflict and the Strait of Hormuz: Impacts on Oil, Gas, and Other Commodities.

    •     Kilian, L., Plante, M., & Richter, A.W. (2026). The Impact of the 2026 Iran War on U.S. and Global Energy Markets. Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas.

    •     J.P. Morgan Private Bank (2024). How Do Geopolitical Shocks Impact Markets?

    •     MSCI (2024). Understanding Geopolitical Risk in Investments.

    •     TIAA. Frequently Asked Questions About TIAA Traditional — withdrawal and transfer provisions by contract type, including the Transfer Payout Annuity mechanism.

    •     Market and oil price data from contemporaneous reporting, February–April 2026.

    This article is educational and general in nature. It is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice, and it does not account for any individual's specific circumstances. Past performance is not indicative of future results; investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. The two-professor scenario is a hypothetical illustration grounded in historical index returns and does not represent any actual client. Current as of April 2026.

    Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®

    Managing Partner, Sr. Wealth Management Advisor, Radiant Wealth Management

    Author, Getting to Emeritus (Johns Hopkins University Press, August 2026)

    dan.fagan@radiantwm.com  |  Office: 475.234.5965  |  Cell: 860.748.2552

    Scheduling: app.greminders.com/c/danfagan

    Radiant Wealth Management is a fee-only practice serving faculty, physicians, and academic professionals. Advisory services offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser.


    About Dan Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience, including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor, Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most.

    This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Individual circumstances vary. Please consult qualified professionals for advice specific to your situation. Advisory services are offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure.