← Insights

    The Behavior Gap: Why Smart Investors Underperform Their Own Investments

    In 2024, the S&P 500 returned 25.05%. The average equity investor earned 16.54%. Same market, same funds available to everyone — and an 848-basis-point gap, the fourth largest in nearly forty years of tracking. The culprit wasn't the market. It was behavior. And if you're an academic or physician, your training doesn't protect you — it may be working against you.

     Here's a number that should stop you cold: 848 basis points.

    That's how much the average equity investor underperformed the S&P 500 in 2024, according to DALBAR's Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behavior — the fourth-largest gap in the nearly forty years the firm has tracked it. The market returned 25.05%. The average investor captured 16.54%.

    And here's what makes it genuinely unsettling: 2024 was a good year. No pandemic, no financial crisis, no black swan — just a straightforward bull market that most investors failed to capture. DALBAR's conclusion was blunt: late re-entries, poor rebalancing, and tactical moves that missed rallies added up to more effort and less return, with behavioral missteps eroding real results even in a favorable market.

    The 2024 result extended a streak: fifteen consecutive years in which the average equity investor trailed the index. The last time investors beat it was 2009. A pattern that persistent isn't a glitch. It's telling you something fundamental about how we're wired.

    The five biases doing the damage

    Behavioral finance has mapped the specific cognitive patterns behind the gap. If you pride yourself on analytical thinking — and my clients, by profession, all do — the uncomfortable news is that intelligence provides no immunity. Sometimes it makes things worse. Here are the five that cost real money.

    Recency bias — the rearview mirror problem. We weight recent events far too heavily against long-term data, which in investing means chasing what just worked and fleeing what just failed. It's why investors held Netflix through 2022 as it fell more than 50% — the previous decade said it always came back — and it's why Nvidia's 1,500%-plus run since 2020 feels inevitable in retrospect, which is precisely the feeling that leads people to extrapolate it forward indefinitely.

    Overconfidence — the expertise trap. This one hits academics and physicians hardest. You've spent decades building genuine expertise. You've been right when others were wrong. You've learned, correctly, to trust your judgment — in your field. Markets don't care about your credentials, and the research is consistent: overconfidence produces excessive trading, concentrated positions, and under-diversification, all of which drag on returns. The skill was real. The transfer is the illusion.

    Confirmation bias — the echo chamber. We seek information that confirms what we already believe and dismiss what contradicts it. If you believe AI dominates the next decade, you'll gravitate toward the analysts who agree; the bearish cases won't land; the warning signs won't register. This was the mechanism inside every bubble in history — in 1999, tech bulls found endless sophisticated reasons why that time was different. They were hearing what they wanted to hear, delivered by people paid to say it well.

    Loss aversion — the pain asymmetry. Losses hurt roughly twice as much as equivalent gains feel good, and that asymmetry drives systematically backwards behavior: holding losers far too long (waiting to "get back to even") while selling winners too early (locking in gains before they can disappear). It's exactly wrong, and it feels exactly right in the moment. That's what makes it dangerous.

    Herding — the crowd instinct. Studies of herd behavior suggest a small informed minority can steer the decisions of nearly everyone else. When everyone seems to be buying the same thing, resisting is extraordinarily hard — and today's index concentration, with the top five companies approaching a quarter of the S&P 500's value, is partly herding at industrial scale. Money flows where money has flowed. (I wrote last month about what that concentration means structurally; this piece is about why your own psychology will resist acting on it.)

    Why intelligence doesn't help

    Cognitive biases aren't failures of intelligence. They're features of human cognition — standard equipment, installed in everyone.

    Your ability to diagnose a patient or design a rigorous study doesn't protect you from recency bias, and your analytical training doesn't override the emotional weight of watching your portfolio drop 20%. The research and my thirty years of sitting across from brilliant people point the same direction: smarter people are better at rationalizing their biases. They're more articulate defending bad decisions. They find sophisticated reasons to do unsophisticated things. Intelligence doesn't protect you from behavioral bias — it gives your anxiety better vocabulary.

    What actually works

    DALBAR's four decades of data keep landing on the same conclusion: investment results depend more on investor behavior than on fund performance. That's the problem and the solution in one sentence — you can't control the market, and you can control your behavior. Four practices, all boring, all effective:

    Systematize your decisions. Write rebalancing rules in advance and put them on a calendar. A decision made once, in calm conditions, beats the same decision remade monthly under emotional load.

    Create friction. Make trading slightly harder, not easier. Turn off real-time portfolio notifications. Check accounts quarterly, not daily — the more often you look, the more often loss aversion gets a vote.

    Use external accountability. This is where an advisor earns their keep — not in stock picking, but in behavioral counterweight: the person whose job is to ask "what changed besides your mood?" before money moves.

    Study your own history. Keep a journal of investment decisions and review it annually. Your own track record will reveal patterns you cannot see from inside the moment.

    The bottom line

    The average investor left 848 basis points on the table in a year when everything went right. Compounded over a career, that gap is worth hundreds of thousands of dollars — more, for the high savers my practice serves, than almost any optimization of funds, fees, or taxes could recover.

    The irony is that the winning strategy usually feels like doing nothing: stay invested, rebalance mechanically, ignore the headlines, trust the process. It sounds simple. Fifteen consecutive years of data say it isn't. Which is exactly why understanding your own psychology might be the most valuable financial skill you ever develop — and why building a structure that doesn't depend on your in-the-moment judgment is the most valuable thing a plan can do.

    If you'd like to see what that structure looks like for your own situation — the rules, the friction, the accountability, set up before the next volatile moment instead of during it — that's what I'm here for. You can grab a time on my calendar — no pressure, just clarity.

    Dan

     

    Sources

    •     DALBAR, Inc., 2025 Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behavior — 2024 results release: average equity investor 16.54% vs. S&P 500 25.05%.

    •     PLANADVISER, Investors' Bad Behavior Led to Sharp Underperformance in 2024 — fourth-largest gap since 1985; fifteen-year streak.

    •     Charles Schwab Asset Management, Recency bias — educational overview and the Netflix case.

    •     Britannica Money, Behavioral biases in finance.

    •     William & Mary Online, Behavioral biases that impact investing decisions — herding research.

    •     Peer-reviewed research on overconfidence and cognitive illusions in investing: ScienceDirect, PMC/NIH.

    This article is educational and general in nature. It is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice, and it does not account for any individual's specific circumstances. DALBAR figures reflect that organization's methodology for measuring average investor returns. Past performance is not indicative of future results; investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Current as of December 2025.

    Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®

    Managing Partner, Sr. Wealth Management Advisor, Radiant Wealth Management

    Author, Getting to Emeritus (Johns Hopkins University Press, August 2026)

    dan.fagan@radiantwm.com  |  Office: 475.234.5965  |  Cell: 860.748.2552

    Scheduling: app.greminders.com/c/danfagan

    Radiant Wealth Management is a fee-only practice serving faculty, physicians, and academic professionals. Advisory services offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser.


    About Dan Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience, including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor, Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most.

    This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Individual circumstances vary. Please consult qualified professionals for advice specific to your situation. Advisory services are offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure.