← Insights

    The Average Returns Myth: The Retirement Math Professors Miss

    Why the number at the center of most retirement projections says almost nothing about whether your plan survives

    If you’ve ever reviewed a retirement projection from TIAA, Fidelity, an online calculator, or a spreadsheet you built yourself, odds are it rests on a single assumption: an average annual return. If you’re within a decade of retirement, that number is doing more work than it can support. This piece explains why average returns describe growth but not durability, and what better questions look like.

    One of the most persistent myths in retirement planning is the idea that average returns tell us what we need to know.

    They don’t.

    Average returns are useful during accumulation. They are far less useful when you are approaching retirement, and actively misleading once withdrawals begin.

    Yet most retirement projections still rely on them.

    Why Average Returns Feel Comforting

    Average returns appeal to our sense of fairness.

    If the market averages 7 percent over the long term, it feels reasonable to assume that patience will smooth out the bumps. For decades, that assumption mostly works while you are contributing and compounding.

    The problem is that retirement breaks the symmetry.

    Once withdrawals begin, the order in which returns arrive matters as much as the average itself.

    That’s not a behavioral issue. It’s arithmetic.

    The Difference Between Growth and Survival

    A portfolio growing over 30 or 40 years can tolerate volatility. Contributions arrive regardless of market conditions. Losses early in your career are often irrelevant in hindsight.

    A portfolio that must support spending is different.

    Losses early in retirement permanently reduce the base from which all future growth and withdrawals must occur. Even strong returns later may not be enough to undo the damage.

    This is why two people can experience the same average return over time and end up in dramatically different places.

    Average returns describe growth. They do not describe durability.

    Why This Matters Most Before Retirement

    The most dangerous moment is not the day you retire. It is the decade leading up to it.

    At that point, new contributions are small relative to portfolio size. Retirement dates are psychologically fixed. And there is limited time to recover from a major drawdown before withdrawals begin.

    A plan built on average returns assumes cooperation from the market at exactly the wrong time.

    That assumption is rarely stated, but it is embedded in many projections.

    What Better Thinking Looks Like

    Better planning replaces averages with stress.

    Instead of asking, “What does this portfolio return on average?” the more useful questions are:

    •             How does it behave if poor returns arrive early?

    •             How sensitive is it to a bad first decade?

    •             How flexible is spending if markets disappoint?

    These questions don’t eliminate risk. They reveal it.

    And they tend to shift planning conversations away from performance and toward structure.

    This Is Not About Predicting Markets

    This is not a call to forecast crashes or abandon growth.

    It is a reminder that markets do not deliver returns in neat, evenly spaced lines. They arrive in clusters. Sometimes helpful. Sometimes destructive.

    Planning that assumes smoothness where none exists is fragile by design.

    Respecting sequence risk is not pessimism. It is realism.

    The Bottom Line

    Average returns make retirement look simpler than it is.

    What determines success is not what the market does over 30 years, but what it does when timing matters most.

    If you are within a decade of retirement and your plan still relies primarily on averages, it may be worth asking whether it has been tested against the moments that matter most.

    That question alone often changes the conversation.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What’s the difference between average return and sequence of returns? Average return is the mean of your yearly returns over a period; sequence is the order in which they arrive. During accumulation, the order barely matters. Once you’re withdrawing, two portfolios with identical averages can end in dramatically different places depending on whether the bad years came first or last.

    Why do retirement calculators mislead? Most assume a smooth, constant return — 6 or 7 percent, every year, forever. Real markets deliver returns in clusters, and a plan that only works when the market cooperates in the early years hasn’t really been tested. The average can be exactly right and the plan can still fail.

    How do I stress test my retirement plan? Model the uncomfortable scenarios directly: poor returns in the first five years of withdrawals, a bad first decade, elevated inflation, and a spending plan that has to flex. The point is to find out where the plan bends before you’re relying on it. Our companion guide covers the practical moves for the five-to-ten-year window.

    Does this mean professors should get out of stocks before retiring? No. Sequence risk is managed with structure: a liquidity buffer that keeps you from selling in a downturn, deliberate duration in the bond allocation, guaranteed income floors where appropriate, and flexible spending. Growth assets still have a long job to do in a retirement that may run thirty years.

    (Internal links for this piece: “Five to Ten Years From Retirement? Here’s What to Protect First” · “Phased Retirement for Professors: The Math Behind the Smartest Year You’ll Ever Work” · “What Bonds Did in 2022 — and What TIAA Traditional Did Instead”)

    Sources & Further Reading

    The ideas in this piece are grounded in well-established academic and institutional research:

    William P. Bengen (1994). Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data. Journal of Financial Planning. https://www.onefpa.org/journal/Pages/Determining%20Withdrawal%20Rates%20Using%20Historical%20Data.aspx

    Wade D. Pfau. Retirement Planning Guidebook and peer-reviewed research on sequence of returns risk. https://retirementresearcher.com

    Morningstar Investment Management. Blanchett, Benz et al., Sequence of Returns Risk in Retirement. https://www.morningstar.com/retirement/sequence-returns-risk

    Michael Kitces. Managing Sequence of Return Risk in Retirement. https://www.kitces.com/blog/sequence-of-return-risk-retirement-withdrawals

    TIAA Institute. Major Risks in Retirement. https://www.tiaainstitute.org/publication/major-risks-retirement

    Vanguard Research. From Assets to Income: A Goals-Based Approach to Retirement. https://corporate.vanguard.com/content/corporatesite/us/en/corp/articles/from-assets-to-income.html

    Ready to talk? Schedule a 30-minute discussion (Zoom or phone). We’ll review your income, benefits, retirement contributions, and legacy planning options — so your next steps are rooted in clarity.

    Daniel Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF® Managing Partner | Sr. Wealth Management Advisor A: 110 Washington Ave., 3rd Floor, North Haven, CT 06473 P: (475) 234-5965 | M: (860) 748-2552 E: dan.fagan@radiantwm.com

    About Dan Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience — including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor — Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most. He is the author of Getting to Emeritus: A Financial Guide for Faculty at Every Career Stage (Johns Hopkins University Press, Summer 2026).

    Advisory services offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure. This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Investing involves risk and possible loss of principal capital. No advice may be rendered by NewEdge Advisors unless a client service agreement is in place.

    Education only — we do not offer tax advice. Please consult your CPA.


    About Dan Dan Fagan, MSPFP, MPAS™, AIF®, is a Senior Wealth Management Advisor and Managing Partner at Radiant Wealth Management in Connecticut. With over 25 years of experience, including 17 years at TIAA as a Senior Wealth Management Advisor, Dan specializes in helping academics and physicians retire smarter, plan with clarity, and align their financial lives with what matters most.

    This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Individual circumstances vary. Please consult qualified professionals for advice specific to your situation. Advisory services are offered through NewEdge Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where NewEdge Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure.